Page 1 of 1


PostPosted: Sat Mar 20, 2004 5:40 am
by justjack
Does anyone else feel like Noto Swing and Just One for Babik sound sort of similar? Is there some connection between these tunes I don't know about? It's just the first couple of bars I'm thinking about.

PostPosted: Sun Mar 21, 2004 1:16 am
by TedGottsegen
They are similar because they are both in minor keys, "Babik" in Gm and "Noto" in Am, however the progressions are different. I have a sheet for "Babik" lying around somewhere...if I can find it amidst all my crap, I'll post the chords.



PostPosted: Sun Mar 21, 2004 6:13 am
by justjack
Hi Ted,

The progressions are definitely different; for Noto, I was looking at the gadjodrom grille, and listening to the version from the Nolan book; for Babik, I've been using this:

What ties them together for me was the melodic similarity in the first two bars, rather than the chord progression. After all, there must be hundreds of tunes that share similar progressions. If you transpose Babik to Am, it (the melody) runs something like this: E, Eb, E, C, C, B, C, E, E. Noto (as I've learned it) runs: E, Eb, E, C, C, B, C, B, C, Bb...

I suppose it's really just that half-step move at the opening leading to the C/B movement; it's such an interesting sound that when I hear it on one tune, I can't help but think of the other, so I wondered if there was some connection historically.


PostPosted: Thu Mar 25, 2004 8:29 pm
by justjack
To backpedal a bit: as I've played them more and more, they seem less and less connected. Last night we tried putting them back to back in a practice and even then they kept their own identities. I wonder why you don't hear Babik more; it's such a great tune, with a very pronounced gypsy feeling, it's too bad it's not displacing another version of All of Me on someone's new record.